David Cronenberg Isn’t a Horror Director

David Cronenberg

David Cronenberg was born on 15 March 1943.

Cronenberg is one of the Big Five horror directors. But he almost doesn’t belong. Sure, he makes horror films. But they are more just Cronenberg films.

What do I mean? Well, what do we make of a film like Dead Ringers? I know. People call it a thriller. But it really isn’t. Thriller is just a word people use when they can’t figure out what else to call a film.

Or Crash? That’s an “erotic thriller”! I’m on board with the erotic in that phrase. But it isn’t a thriller. Nor are most of his films. He simply has too unusual an artistic vision to be crammed into any one genre.

Consider The Fly. It is a great film and you can certainly call it horror. But it doesn’t fit either all that well. Cronenberg isn’t really trying to scare or disgust the audience. The horror that is there is about Brundle and what he is doing to himself. We generally aren’t afraid for anyone else. I would say the same for Videodrome. Other than the conspiracy subplot, it’s pretty much the same story!

Then, of course, there are David Cronenberg’s normal films. First, there is Fast Company. Admittedly, he was more or less a director for hire on that one. Then there is The Dead Zone, which is based on a Stephen King novel, but is one of Cronenberg’s most straightforward efforts.

But 2005 came. And this was the start of a disappointing decade. Cronenberg made A History of Violence, Eastern Promises, A Dangerous Method, Cosmopolis, and Maps to the Stars. Don’t get me wrong. Each of these is a good film. And I adore the last act of Cosmopolis. But, as weird as they all are, they just aren’t at the level of weird that I expect from Cronenberg.

But he came back with some classic body horror in Crimes of the Future. (Not to be confused with his early and deeply disturbing short film of the same name.) Then he made another body horror film, The Shrouds. We all return to our authentic selves — as long as something strange isn’t growing inside us.

Let’s watch one of the best David Cronenberg films that few have seen, Spider. It isn’t terribly psychotronic. But it is very disturbing!


Image cropped from David Cronenberg by Colleen Sturtevant under CC BY-SA 4.0.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *