
Last week, I was visiting my younger sister. She has rather good taste in films. But I consider them kind of highbrow and sentimental. So we watched Remarkably Bright Creatures and the whole time I was marveling at how similar it was to the much vilified but actually quite wonderful A Talking Cat!?!
Remarkably Bright Creatures tells the story of two lost people (Sally Field as Tova and Lewis Pullman as Cameron) who — with the help of each other and a captive octopus (Marcellus, voiced by Alfred Molina) — find meaning and happiness.
The weird thing about the film is that the octopus narrates the story. If it weren’t for that, the film would be more along the lines of Turtle Diary: a serious film about people. But instead, we get intermitten narration by an octopus, which wants to help the human characters. Like I said: A Talking Cat!?!

But it’s bizarre here! The octopus wants to help Tova and Cameron. But all it manages to do is save Cameron’s mother’s ring. And despite Molina’s best efforts to make the octopus sound thoughtful and serious, this whole aspect of the film just seems silly. The film would work better if there was no chatty octopus. Then, at the end, when we discover the ring, we could wonder, “Did that octopus just…?”
I prefer A Talking Cat!?! I like my silly pure. And the producers of Remarkably Bright Creatures do everything they can to hide its silliness. As I said, they could have dropped it. But I assume people who read the book would have been unhappy. And critics seem to have liked the film.
But A Talking Cat!?! features a magic cat that actively engages with the plot by (Get this!) talking to people. But it only does it once per person because, unlike Nam, there are rules. But you do you. I still enjoyed Remarkably Bright Creatures. It’s a sweet film. But it is melodrama and, surprisingly, A Talking Cat!?! isn’t. Yet people take the octopus film more seriously!
Remarkably Bright Creatures (2026) poster via Wikipedia under Fair Use. A Talking Cat!?! (2013) poster via Wikipedia under Fair Use.
