
Sergio Leone was born on 3 January 1929 in Rome — where he died a bit more of 60 years later.
Leone didn’t direct many films. He worked extensively as an assistant and second-unit director. But he got a break on The Last Days of Pompeii. He was second-unit director on the film (and co-writer). The film’s director, Mario Bonnard, fell ill. So the producers hired Leone to finish the film.
He leveraged this and other fixer exploits to get his first feature film, The Colossus of Rhodes. It is a sword-and-sandal epic and quite good, especially if you like that kind of thing. The special effects are particularly good. The main problem is that it is far too long. Leone’s films usually suffered from this. But unlike later, it doesn’t feel padded.
I know! How can I say such a thing about this great director?! To be honest, I think critic’s love of Sergio Leone harmed him even more than they harmed Alfred Hitchcock. Producers really needed to rein in Leone. Most of his films are badly in need of cutting.
Once Upon a Time in America is the ultimate example of this. As with everything Leone did, it features lots of great moments. But regardless of the cut, it makes little sense and is generally boring. After Colossus, only A Fistful of Dollars plays like it was made for audiences not already convinced of his “genius.”
This is harsh, I know. But I’ve been watching his films for decades. The first adult film I liked was A Fistful of Dollars. And there are things I like in all of them. But in addition to the padding, his excessive flashbacks never work and his weird sexual hangups are displayed on the screen as pure misogyny.
Finally, he made very few films. I asked Google why he made so few films and it responded that it was “due to his perfectionist, slow-paced approach, focusing on immense artistic detail and long production times.” AIs are great at pumping out conventional wisdom. And that there is a great example of why Leone was allowed to make his bloated and excessively mean films.
Just the same, Sergio Leone made nothing but psychotronic films. And I admire that! I recommend watching The Colossus of Rhodes. But I know most people won’t, so let’s watch his masterpiece, A Fistful of Dollars.
Note: I wrote more about this on the anniversary of the US release of Once Upon a Time in the West.
Sergio Leone via Wikimedia. It is in the public domain.



















